Archive for the 'Ratings' Category

WAR

Nov 21, 2007 in 2 Stars, Facebook, Gaming

Rating: ★★☆☆☆

WAR is a Facebook implementation of the classic card game of WAR. You probably remember this game from your child hood. It’s about the simplest standard 52-card deck game around.

Classic WAR

In the classic game of WAR the deck is divided evenly amongst each player and then each player draws and flips a card. The player with the highest card wins and gets all of the cards from that hand. In the event of a tie you go to “war”. When you go to war you each place 3 cards face down and flip over a 4th card. The winner of a war gets all of the cards from that hand including the face down ones. In the event of another tie during war, this process is repeated. The player who wins all (or most) of the cards in the end is declared the winner.

Facebook WAR

In the Facebook version of WAR each player is given 5 cards face down. Each player flips their cards over in order, one card per hand. Each player is awarded 2 points for each winning hand per game and 1 bonus point for each game won.

WAR

While this sounds like a lot of fun and may bring back childhood nostalgia like wonder, it really isn’t. Either the game of WAR never was fun and we were all just once naive children or this implementation is poorly executed. The main problem with WAR for Facebook is how SLOW it is. Unfortunately each player has to log in and flip their card over manually each hand, one card per hand and then wait for their opponent to log back in and flip their card. Now there is nothing wrong with turn based games, especially casual gaming of Facebook, but usually those games involve some kind of action or entertainment per turn or hand. Logging in to flip a card for a 50/50 chance of winning with no skill at all involved is just not fun.

I had hoped this would be much more exciting, I have fond memories of endless hours of playing WAR as a child but Facebook WAR just does not live up to those expectations. If anyone is friends with the authors; Shashank Senapaty, Matt, and Shrikrishna Shrin please SuperPoke! them and tell them to put the fun back in WAR!

The Result

Uninstalled after the week it took to complete one game.

Add Application

Know Me Well

Nov 21, 2007 in 3 Stars, Facebook

Rating: ★★★☆☆

The Know Me Well Facebook application written by Chris Sim works like those the chain-mail personality quizzes you’ve been getting in your inbox for the last 10 years.

After installing the application, you’re prompted to fill out some simple yes/no questions. How many you answer is up to you, but you need to submit at least 20 answers.

knowmewellquestions

After you are done submitting your answers, you are given the chance to test your knowledge of your friends. There are some questions you could possibly never know the answer too, but that doesn’t mean you can’t use your intuition.

knowmewellresults

I like the application. It’s easy to use and intuitive. I would have given it 4 stars, if it had different question profiles on specific topics (like some other similar apps). But even with just 200 questions, getting high scores is a lot harder than you might think.

Installed

Add Application

Birthday Calendar

Nov 21, 2007 in 3 Stars, Facebook

Rating: ★★★☆☆

birthdaycalendar

As someone who’s notoriously bad at dates, I thought I’d give the Birthday Calendar application a shot.

After installing the application, I was worried that I would need to invite all my friends to use the application in order to derive any usefulness from it. That was not the case! You can simply skip this step and immediately get a calendar view of all your friends birthdays.

birthdaycalendarview

Note, it was recently my birthday and gifts are still being accepted.

Clicking on a person’s profile picture opens up a new page which lets you send birthday greeting cards. The catch is, they are not sent on the Facebook platform, but instead link to http://www.birthdays-calendar.com/. These greeting cards are actually sent via the mail, so there’s a fee associated with sending a greeting card.

The other semi-useful feature of the application is to send alerts. Using the Facebook API they can notify you of up to 20 birthdays per day (Limited by the Facebook API). The catch is it forces your friends to add the application in order for you to receive the alerts (the viral component).

Overall, it’s an application I’ll keep installed. The birthday overview calendar provides enough usefulness. I don’t think I’ll fall for their upsell strategy, but they provide quick links to Facebook gift giving options as well.

Installed

Add Application

Which Olsen Twin Are You?

Nov 21, 2007 in 1 Star, Facebook

Rating: ★☆☆☆☆

Yes — that’s right, the answer to life’s looming question is finally here! Which Olsen Twin Are You? is the Facebook application designed to help you sleep at night by riding your subconscious of this burning question. Brought to us by the minds of Katherine Barscay and Tomas Lin.

Mary-Kate or Ashley?

Which Olsen Twin Are You? presents you with two columns of choices that you are to choose your favorite from for each row. There’s about 10 questions in total. Based on your answers it then proceeds to tell you which Olsen twin you are. My results: Ashley.

What Olsen Twin Are You: Ashley

Katherine and Tomas claim this app was inspired by the following video. Does Facebook need applications like this? You decide.

[[yt:ecybaR_Th5o]]

The Result

After spending about 1-2 minutes installing this application and answering the questions to have the answer revealed to me I can honestly say I will no longer wonder which Olsen Twin I am. So what’s the point of having this in my profile box?

What Olsen Twin Are You Profile Box

Uninstalled

Add Application